State
of Child Labour in Bangladesh 2001
Background:
Bangladesh
is predominantly an agrarian society. By certain estimates,
the country at present has a population of 1.30 million. The
frequent occurrence of natural disaster compounded by political
upheavals and mal-governance has contributed to slow growth
and prevailing poverty. The situation of child labour in Bangladesh
has become increasingly complex. The population at the grass
roots level are unable to rise above the poverty line resulting
in the increase of unemployment and movement /migration of
individuals and families from the rural areas to urban areas.
Each and every member of the family is required to engage
in some form of economic activity to sustain the family. Even
the youngest member of the family is no longer excluded from
such contributions.
Inadequate
resources and lack of opportunities necessitates engagement
of all members in a family in some form of work. The issue
of child labour has become acute. Child labour is a social
problem. In this densely populated Bangladesh millions of
children are suffering from malnutrition and diseases leading
to death regularly. Those who survive are often deprived of
parental care and support. Their fundamental rights are being
violated. The mere needs to survive is pushing these children
into hazardous labour. This situation involves taking major
risks and being at the receiving end of harassment including
sexual harassment.
Natural
disaster, deterioration of the environment and gradual rise
in poverty, illiteracy and inequitable distribution of wealth,
compounded with lack of awareness of laws related to child
labour and their enforcement is steadfastly contributing to
the increase of child labour. The situation is not improving,
as there is no serious efforts in either the public or private
sector to offer redress and alleviate child labour.
It would
be extremely difficult to describe and explain a complex issue
such as child labour in a paragraph or two. It would require
an extensive research and that too at the national level.
Viewed from the perspective of social problem child labour
is closely tied with the issue of child rights. The few study
or research done to date have emerged from individuals and
organizations working to understand or establish child rights.
However, an extensive research is yet to be undertaken. Towards
this end Shishu Adhikar Forum (BSAF) engaged in this exercise.
Till date
no research based on urban and rural context or on a geographical
basis is available. Therefore, BSAF undertook this research
keeping in mind the above consideration. The findings of this
research highlight in both urban and rural context 430 types
of child labour prevalent at present.
Contents
Summary
Rationale of the Study
Methodology & Objectives of the Project
Barriers/ Impediments to the Research
Children & Child Labour
Causes of Child Labour in Bangladesh
Causes of Increasing Child Labour in Bangladesh
Scope of Child Labour in Bangladesh
Hazardous Child Labour & its Description
Detail Basic Information Regarding Profession of Children
Engaged in Hazardous Works
Domestic Laws at a glance relating to Child Labour
Child Labour Laws & Legal measures for the Law Breakers
Remarks & Presumption of Interviewees of the Organizations
Visited in relation to Existing Laws
ILO Convention 182
Survey on Child Labour at Divisional Level
Areas visited in 6 Divisions for Research
Recommendations of Interviewees of different Organizations
Conclusion
Case Studies
Bibliography
List of organizations who helped providing information, journals
and research documents during research
Acronyms
Summary
Bangladesh
is a developing country with majority of its population being
engaged in some form of labour with children forming a sizeable
portion of the informal labour force. At an age when these
children should be attending school they are involved in the
struggle for survival. They take on the responsibilities of
the family at an early age. They enter into many hazardous
jobs. Without any hesitation it can be stated that despite
the discourse and debate on child labour and its elimination
there is not enough initiatives either in the government or
non-government sector to combat it. The interventions are
far from being adequate.
It may
be mentioned that BSAF took up this research on child labour
which culminated in the report “State of Child Labour
in Bangladesh 2001.” The research was able to identify
450 forms of child labour in 6 divisions comprising of districts
and upazillas. Of these, 67 forms of jobs were identified
as extremely hazardous for children. These have been discussed
in the formal, informal, rural, urban and regional context
in the report. The report records and discusses the programmatic
interventions of BSAF’s member organizations in the
districts and upazillas, reflecting the views and opinions
of the member organizations. Case studies of child labour
have been incorporated in the report. As a result, related
and important information on child labour is available in
this report.
Rationale
Little
research work has been done on child labour, which does not
provide in-depth understanding of the problem. It is important
have an understanding of the status of children to work on
the issue. In addition, it is to be known about the organizations
working with children at the grassroots level and to prepare
a one-stop database compiling the relevant research works.
It was considered as an useful exercise to document if possible,
if not list the best practices in this field. It may contribute
or influence planning of organizations and individuals at
micro or macro level compiling the recommendations and presumptions
of the organizations that has been doing good works to eliminate
child labour or attempting to so that the development activists
could initiate some work in their localities based on this
research work.
With the
expansion of the working sector in Bangladesh it is noticed
that the nature and scope of hazardous child labour is increasing
gradually. One of the objectives of this research was to identify
these sectors in consultation with the grassroots NGOs. At
present there is no information of such research to enable
comparative analysis. This research has resulted in a report,
which includes major information relating to child labour
that will help engage the researchers to do in-depth study
on the issue, which in turn, is expected to help develop policies
and initiatives to eliminate child labour.
Research Methodology
The methods
and techniques of the study entitled “State of Child
Labour in Bangladesh” have been designed through a 3-day
workshop where the Director of BSAF, consultant and study
team were present. These are:
Issues of the
Workshop
o The subject matter of
the Research and demand;
o The process of selection
of the formal and informal sector;
o Discussion on hazardous
child labour;
o Directions in relation
to the objectives of the research;
o Guidelines in relation
to the methodology of the research;
o Formulation of Questionnaire;
o Guidelines for the use
of Questionnaire;
o One to one discussion.
Objectives
o To understand the real
status of child labour in Bangladesh;
o To create a reliable
database on child labour in Bangladesh;
o To develop an understanding
of the relative increase in child labour;
o To raise awareness with
the intent to contribute in the process of eliminating child
labour;
o To develop an comprehensive
understanding of the nature and extent of hazardous child
labour;
o To compile opinion,
views/suggestions from organization in the region working
with children and child rights;
o To collect information
and form an understanding regarding programmatic interventions
by NGOs for the elimination of child labour
Impediments
a) Time: Three months is inadequate to undertake
a research requiring in-depth interview and observation from
different parts of the country.
b)
Sample: The sample of the research involves children
across Bangladesh engaged in various forms of hazardous work.
It is not sufficient for the study to collect information
and observe children at the field level only in a few districts
and upazilas of the 6 Divisions. However, despite limitations
the information has been collected from organizations engaged
in programmes targeting children.
c)
Environment: May - July is the height of the monsoon
season in Bangladesh and many regions are flooded. Therefore,
the researchers had to face difficulties in collecting information.
d)
Budget: Due to budget constraints a very small group
of researchers collected required information from the upazilas
and districts of the 6 Divisions.
e)
Non-cooperation: It was difficult to gather information
from the employers of children in hazardous jobs due to non-cooperation.
Moreover, on many occasions the researchers had to visit an
organization several times for interviewing the targeted individuals
resulting in a time consuming exercise.
Children and Child
Labour
Who is a Child?
A child
can be defined within the purview of international labour
standard. As per ILO convention (Convention - 138), any person
below 15 years of age is called child. The Convention of the
Rights of the Child (1989) defines a person below the age
of 18 years as a ‘child.’ Domestic labour laws
in Bangladesh define child in various ways. The Children Employment
Act, 1938 defines person below 15 years of age as child. According
to the Factory Act, 1965 person below 16 years is called a
child. A person under 14 years of age can be considered child
as recommended by The National Labour Law Commission in 1992.
Who are Child
Labourers?
The children
engaged in labour force are mostly from unjust society or
disadvantaged families do work mainly for three reasons:
o Earning money in exchange
of labour;
o Getting food, cloth
and accommodation;
o Learning by doing.
Based on these, the disadvantaged
children can be termed child labourers who are engaged in
labour market in order to earn their livelihood.
Child Labour and
the Nature of Work
Almost
all children are required to perform certain tasks, which
are not necessarily hazardous. These contribute to their well
being as well as that of their families. However, there are
certain jobs, which are harmful to the children and are also
considered exploitative. Unicef has identified these as child
labour. When children undertake jobs which are risky in regards
to their age, exploitative in nature and in conflict with
the existing laws, it is identified as child labour. The formal
as well as informal child labour which is physically, mentally
and morally harmful to children and do not commensurate with
their needs and rights can be called child labour. However,
any productive work which is conducive to the physical, mental
and moral development of a child can be considered as child’s
work.
Causes of Child
Labour in Bangladesh
Child
labour is the product of socio-economic reality of Bangladesh.
The Status of Child Labour in Bangladesh, 1996 revealed three
factors responsible for child labour:
Push
Factor: The factors that compel a child to engage
in the labour force for survival is called push factor. Acute
poverty, death of family earner/father, abandoned by parents
and natural calamities are the major factors that lead children
towards labour market.
Attraction:
With the increasing demand of labour force in the labour market
there is a propensity of employing children as cheap labour
by the factory owners or other employers. There are some gleaming
things in urban areas that attract children towards labour
market. Most of the employers employ children as because children
are cheap and they can be easily persuaded to work long hours.
In addition, they have minimal wage demands and are easily
manageable.
Socio-psychological
Factor: Due to failure in life, socio-psychological
problem i.e. being frightened of parents and deception of
family members, children engage in labour force for survival
and sometime prefer a nomadic life.
Causes of increasing
Child Labour in Bangladesh:
Geographical
Cause: Geographically Bangladesh is surrounded in
three sides by India and Mayanmar. Most areas are surrounded
by rivers and some by haor and hills. Excessive rain, drought,
flood and cyclone are regular phenomenon in Bangladesh. These
contribute in various ways to the promotion of child labour
discourse and also contribute to the increase of child labour.
Social
Cause: The poor section of people are subjected to
various exploitation by the well-to-do people. Illiteracy,
unemployment and abuse of power by the elite results in the
poor section of the people remaining at a disadvantaged position.
Religious and cultural practices compound the problem.
Economic
Reason: Development and economic growth is inadequate
in comparison to its population growth. There are not enough
economic opportunities for majority of the rural population
leading to poverty remaining a major problem. Children from
such poverty ridden families are thrust into the labour market
eventually.
Pseudo-Unemployment:
Due to scarcity of work and lack of scope for skilled labour,
some people take up low income jobs and run their families
on this income with great difficulty. At times they lead their
children to labour market stopping their school.
Polygamy:
Due to the practice of polygamy a man may have several wives
and children and is unable to provide food, clothing and shelter
for all. As a result children from such families may end up
joining the labour market.
Addiction:
An addicted person spends the lion share of his/her earnings
in addiction and due to insolvency of the family, children
engage in labour market.
Ineffectiveness
of Law: Due to lack of enforcement of the existing
Labour Laws, a section of owners - mostly profit oriented
encourage children in labour force.
Inadequacy
of Law: An absence of clear and specific laws to
address issues and problems of child labour, children are
entering the labour force and there is acceptance and no major
deterrent.
More......